FEDEA
Comentario a la Proposición de Ley para el establecimiento de gravámenes temporales sobre determinadas empresas energéticas y entidades de crédito

Calling into question the tax on banks and utilities

The Foundation for Applied Economics Studies (Fedea) has published a very critical note signed by its Director, Angel de la Fuente, pointing out the "arbitrariness" of the new extraordinary taxes on the financial and energy sectors announced last July by Pedro Sánchez and seconded by the parties that make up and support the coalition government.

Main conclusions of the analysis:

  • A controversial aspect of the proposal is that it grants the new taxes the status of a non-tax public contribution (a figure designed for the financing of public services provided under concession).

  • Fedea points out that "the main problem of the text is the arbitrariness of these new levies created ad hoc".

  • The proposal seeks to "interfere with the free functioning of companies and markets, to try to preset by law the effective distribution of the burden of a tax regardless of market conditions, which are those that determine the real incidence of taxes in an unplanned economy".

  • The objective is to place the blame on sectors that "can benefit the most from the rise in prices through an improvement in their margins". However, "neither banks nor utilities are among the most profitable sectors in Spain 2021. Clearly ahead the industry, commerce and hospitality and even more profitable the information and communications sector". Thus, its author insists that "no minimally consistent reasons are offered to support the thesis that the new taxes are not arbitrary levies but rather well-proportioned contributions”.

  • Regarding the provision of the proposal that forbids the direct or indirect passing on of the levy to the customers of the companies affected (and which entrusts the CNMC, with the collaboration of the Bank of Spain, to monitor compliance with this prohibition), Ángel de la Fuente stresses that this "represents an attack that is difficult to justify against the freedom of enterprise, which is constitutionally protected. Ensuring that the increase in a specific item of costs is not passed on is mission impossible, but establishing the obligation to try to do so may open up a dangerous path towards direct interference with business decisions in which the government should not interfere".

Filter results

FILTER BY CATEGORIES()
BACK

Filter results

Categories

23/10/2025

According to Kristalina Georgeva IMF Managing Director, lifting growth requires three things: one, regulatory housecleaning to unleash private enterprise; two, deeper regional integration; and three, preparedness to harness AI.

International Monetary Fund
World Economic Outlook and Global Financial Stability reports, October 2025
15/10/2025

According to The European House – Ambrosetti, the European Union has an opportunity to boost competitiveness and growth by simplifying regulatory and supervisory frameworks, particularly in the areas of sustainability and the financial sector.

The European House- Ambrosetti
Europe’s Competitiveness at Crossroads: A Stocktaking one year after the Draghi and Letta Reports
15/10/2025

According to Ramón Casilda Béjar, Spain, in today’s complex geopolitical landscape, has the opportunity to strengthen its role as a bridge and connecting country between Ibero-America and the European Union, revitalizing investment flows in both directions.

Instituto Español de Estudios Estratégicos
Revitalizar el espacio inversor iberoamericano con España como puente y país vertebrador con la Unión Europea
25/09/2025

According to @ECB, in moments of acute stress, the public often turns to physical currency as a reliable store of value and a resilient means of payment, underscoring the crucial role it plays above and beyond everyday transactional convenience

European Central Bank, Francesca Faella and Alejandro Zamora-Pérez
Keep calm and carry cash: lessons on the unique role of physical currency across four crises
25/09/2025

According to Juan S. Mora-Sanguinetti, in Spain a 10% increase in regulatory volume leads to a 0.5% drop in employment in companies with fewer than 10 employees.

Banco de España, Juan S. Mora-Sanguinetti
La complejidad normativa en España: un freno para las empresas y el crecimiento económico
17/09/2025

According to Hélène Rey “In a world where stablecoins, particularly those pegged to the dollar, become an important global payment tool, we must brace ourselves for substantial consequences”.

International Monetary Fund
Stablecoins, Tokens, and Global Dominance
17/09/2025

@judith_arnal proposes reforms for the EU to advance regulatory simplification, starting with consensus on its meaning, with competitiveness as a pillar, plus coordination mechanisms and a governance rethink.

CEPS
EU simplification will fail without better governance: three necessary reforms to make sure it doesn’t fail
Judith Arnal
03/07/2025

According to @iee_org, Spain has one of the most demanding tax environments for businesses within the European and international context, which may have significant implications for competitiveness, foreign investment attraction, and business expansion.

Instituto de Estudios Económicos
Competitividad fiscal empresarial 2025
19/06/2025

According to Christine Lagarde for the euro to gain in status, Europe must take decisive steps by completing the single market, reducing regulatory burdens and building a robust capital markets union.

Christine Lagarde, President of the ECB
Europe’s “global euro” moment
29/05/2025

According to the Bank of Spain, in a context of strong growth in transactions and prices, the conditions under which new mortgage loans are granted currently show no signs of easing in lending standards.

Bank of Spain
Informe de Estabilidad Financiera. Primavera 2025
08/05/2025

McKinsey notes that European private capital is half the size of the U.S. and must play a key role in boosting competitiveness, by driving innovation, scaling firms, and mobilizing the investment needed to close the gap with other regions.

Mckinsey 6 Company
Private capital: The key to boosting European competitiveness
24/04/2025

IMF states that global financial stability risks have grown significantly, driven by tighter financial conditions and heightened trade and geopolitical uncertainty.

International Monetary Fund
Global Financial Stability report, April 2025
URL copied to clipboard