The new banking tax and the rule of law
The Institute of Economic Studies (IEE) published a report, elaborated by experts in financial and tax law, assessing the legality of the government's proposal to levy a temporary charge on the banking and energy sector. The report considers that the proposal, in addition to be considered a fraud of law, by eluding essential parliamentary procedures to approve a tax, presents serious problems from the constitutional point of view and violates basic aspects of the European Union (EU) law.
The report provides several legal comments on the deficiencies found in the government proposal, out of which we highlight the following:
- The legal formula chosen by the government may be faster but it suffers from serious formal defects: According to the report, since it is a tax and not a " non-tax financial contribution to the State", the "Proposal Law" evades the due parliamentary procedure for the Government to exercise its right of legislative initiative: public consultation, regulatory impact review and a report by the Government’s Council of State, State, which would have occurred if it had been introduced as a “Government Bill” (Proyecto de Ley).
- It suffers from serious technical defects that could violate the Spanish Constitution and the European Union legal framework. For example:
-Disregards the prohibition of discrimination between residents and non-residents since it is expected to apply only to resident financial entities and not to subsidiaries of foreign entities.
- It violates the principle of legal certainty by establishing the retroactivity of the charge to facts that occurred prior to both when it will take effect and the year it must be paid.
- Disregards the regime for financing the Autonomous Regions and their participation in the collection of state taxes.
- Regarding the concept of "windfall profits" in the banking sector, the report comments that it is difficult to speak of "extraordinary profits" in a sector characterized in recent years by its narrow margins and low return on equity even below than its cost of capital'. In addition, the government's proposal establishes a direct relationship between rate hikes and higher profits, ignoring relevant aspects such as the evolution of the demand of credit in a crisis scenario or the increase in non-performing loans, in addition to the relationship between profits and capital invested, which is what determines the profitability of an entity.
Filter results
According to the OECD. SMEs and start-ups that grow rapidly contribute significantly to job creation, economic growth and competitiveness. Indeed, SMEs that grow by one-third over a three-year period, contribute about as much to job creation as large firms.
According to @McKinsey, banks must prepare for a new growth curve. Strategic precision —the ability to combine technology, capital discipline, and deep customer insight— will distinguish the leaders from the laggards.
According to Kristalina Georgeva IMF Managing Director, lifting growth requires three things: one, regulatory housecleaning to unleash private enterprise; two, deeper regional integration; and three, preparedness to harness AI.
According to The European House – Ambrosetti, the European Union has an opportunity to boost competitiveness and growth by simplifying regulatory and supervisory frameworks, particularly in the areas of sustainability and the financial sector.
According to Ramón Casilda Béjar, Spain, in today’s complex geopolitical landscape, has the opportunity to strengthen its role as a bridge and connecting country between Ibero-America and the European Union, revitalizing investment flows in both directions.
According to @ECB, in moments of acute stress, the public often turns to physical currency as a reliable store of value and a resilient means of payment, underscoring the crucial role it plays above and beyond everyday transactional convenience
According to Juan S. Mora-Sanguinetti, in Spain a 10% increase in regulatory volume leads to a 0.5% drop in employment in companies with fewer than 10 employees.
According to Hélène Rey “In a world where stablecoins, particularly those pegged to the dollar, become an important global payment tool, we must brace ourselves for substantial consequences”.
@judith_arnal proposes reforms for the EU to advance regulatory simplification, starting with consensus on its meaning, with competitiveness as a pillar, plus coordination mechanisms and a governance rethink.
According to @iee_org, Spain has one of the most demanding tax environments for businesses within the European and international context, which may have significant implications for competitiveness, foreign investment attraction, and business expansion.
According to Christine Lagarde for the euro to gain in status, Europe must take decisive steps by completing the single market, reducing regulatory burdens and building a robust capital markets union.
According to the Bank of Spain, in a context of strong growth in transactions and prices, the conditions under which new mortgage loans are granted currently show no signs of easing in lending standards.